shopping cart with interest rates

Shopping For A Mortgage Rate Is Just Like Dating! Here’s Why You Keep Getting Burned…

August 03, 20264 min read

The Messman Mortgage Playbook Logo

Shopping for a Mortgage Rate is just like dating! Here’s why you keep getting burned…

You know that friend who swipes through five dating apps at once, chasing whoever seems the most exciting that week? They never settledown. They never build anything real and some how they’re always confused about why every “relationship” falls apart before it starts.

That’s most peoples hopping for a mortgage rate, and no, you’r enot the exception. Sorry.

You call three lenders. You get three numbers. You pick the lowest one and feel like you won.Congratulations, you won a number!!! Did you ask what came with it? Did you ask what’s hiding in the closing costs, or how long that rate is actually locked, or whether that loan officer will remember your name after the ink dries? No? Then you didn’t win anything. You just fell for a great opening line.

The truth is the rate is not the relationship. It’s the pickup line and we all know pickup lines lie.

Chase the Number Instead of Checking the Fit

Think about the last time someone came on way too strong right out of the gate.Great opening line, big promises,and absolutely nothing behind it once you actually got to know them? That’s what a rock bottom rate often looks like in mortgage form. Someone quotes you a number that sounds too good, and by the time you get to the closing table, the fees have quietly made up the difference. Your actual cost never moved. It just got dressed up differently.

Ask yourself something before you get swept off your feet by the headline rate.What are the total closing costs?Are there points? Is this rate locked, or is it floating around waiting for a lender to feel like committing? Because a number without those answers isn’t a deal. It’s a line at a bar.

You Cannot Outsmart the Market, So Stop Trying to Be a Genius.

Some borrowers treat rate shopping like they’re personally going to out maneuver the Federal Reserve. They wait for the “perfect moment.”.They stall a purchase because they heard rates might drop next month. They call ten lenders hoping one of them has a secret back channel to a better market that the other nine somehow missed.

Newsflash. Nobody has the back channel. Rates move on inflation data, bond yields, and global events that could not care less about your closing date. If someone tells you they can time the market for you, ask them a simple question. If you’re that good at predicting the market, why are you still working here quoting mortgages instead of running a hedge fund?

That question usually ends the conversationpretty quickly.😊

Loyalty Beats a Fling Every Single Time

Here’s where the dating comparison really lands. The person who dates around forever, chasing the next best thing, usually ends up starting from zero over and over. Meanwhile, the person who commits to someone who actually shows up for them builds something that lasts.That relationship compounds. It gets stronger with time, not weaker.

Your lender relationship should work the same way, minus the flowers.

When you find a loan officer who answers your questions straight, who explains the tradeoffs instead of just pitching a number, and who treats your loan like it matters…ask yourself this. Is it worth chasing an eighth of a point somewhere else, or is it worth keeping the person who already knows your file, your goals, and your next move before you finish the sentence? That person remembers you when it’s time to refinance. They already understand your plan when you pick up the next investment property.They pick up the phone when a window opens that actually fits what you’re doing.

That is not a one-time transaction. That is a partnership and partnerships are what get you through the next purchase, the next refinance, and the next deal after that, without starting the whole search over from scratch every single time.

What This Actually Means for You

Before you chase the next flashy rate quote around town like it owes you something, ask yourself a few questions.

Does this number include everything or is it missing pieces I have not asked about yet? Am I comparing total cost, or am I just comparing headlines that sound good in a text message? Is this someone I want handling my next loan too, or just this one before I ghost them?

You are not looking for the loudest offer. You are looking for the right fit. Just like dating, the right fit rarely shows up shouting the loudest. Its hows up consistent, honest, and still around after the excitement wears off and the real work starts.

Back to Blog